Fracking, Shale Gas and Children’s Health: Toxins and Vulnerable Populations
By Barb Harris
When it comes to exposure to hazardous chemicals, children are not just little adults. “Children are more vulnerable to environmental hazards,” states the Pediatric Environmental Health Specialty Unit, a subcommittee of the American Pediatric Society. “They eat, drink and breathe more than adults on a pound for pound basis.”(1) This means children are proportionally more exposed to toxins in air, water and food.
In areas of unconventional gas development, children are exposed to multiple industrial toxins, through air, and potentially through water and soil. Yet children’s health remains one of the many unexamined issues of this contentious industry.
Photo Credit: J. Henry Fair, Industrial Scars
Shale gas development creates a widespread network of open-air industrial sites. Well pads can be located close to rural and urban communities. In Pennsylvania, more than 3,000 gas fracking wells and permitted well sites were identified within two miles of 320 day care centers, 67 schools and nine hospitals, and the industry was still growing.
Not only are children proportionally more exposed to toxins, children’s immature bodies are less able to metabolize some toxic substances. This means children are more vulnerable when they are exposed. Young children and babies in the womb are especially vulnerable. In these early stages, children go through critical periods of development when even small exposures to toxins can result in serious, lifelong harm.
In Pavillion, Wyoming, a three-year Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) study documented that 10 chemicals used in fracking were present in the town’s aquifer. Those chemicals included benzene at 50 times the level considered safe, as well as phenols, naphthalene and traces of diesel fuel – all of which are carcinogens. Other toxic chemicals including toluene, a nervous system toxin, were also found.
In situations where drinking water becomes contaminated, children are particularly vulnerable. New studies are indicating that water contamination from unconventional gas operations involving fracking may take place through a variety of routes, over a period of many years.(2) The American Academy of Pediatrics “recommends that families with private drinking water wells in NGE/HF [natural gas extraction/hydraulic fracturing] areas should consider testing the wells before drilling begins and on a regular basis thereafter for chloride, sodium, barium, strontium, and VOCs…”
Children are also at risk from exposure to airborne toxins generated at many stages of shale gas extraction – including drilling, fracking, leaks from condensate tanks and pipelines, wastewater ponds, and the ever-present 18-wheelers.
Benzene is one of the air pollutants frequently found in areas with shale gas development. It is released from flaring gas wells, condensate tanks, and wastewater storage ponds. Benzene is a known carcinogen. Exposure to benzene during pregnancy has been shown to increase rates of childhood leukemia.
In Dish, Texas, air sampling found benzene at levels up to 55 times higher than allowable safety levels. In Colorado and New Mexico, citizen air sampling documented high concentrations of benzene in four of nine air samples, according to Gassed: Citizen Investigation of Toxic Air Pollution from Natural Gas Development. Benzene was found at levels 48.5 to 800 times higher than the US EPA level used to estimate increased cancer risk from long-term exposure. One sample was collected outside an elementary school in Durango, Colorado. Benzene is also a blood and nervous system toxin.
The Gassed study also measured acrylonitrile, a carcinogen, in five of nine samples, ranging from 790 to 3000 times above the U.S. EPA level for increased cancer risk from long term exposure. All levels corresponded to what the EPA would consider an “unacceptable cancer risk.”(3) Acrylonitrile is also a respiratory toxin.
Shale itself contains toxins – including benzene, radioactive elements such as radium 226 with a half life of 1600 years, and heavy metals, including lead, uranium, and arsenic. Fracking releases toxins from the shale, generating millions of gallons of newly toxic and radioactive wastewater as well as tons of toxic and radioactive sand and mud. These waste products often remain in open ponds or piles for years, releasing volatile compounds into air, and with the potential of leaching water-soluble toxins into surrounding soil and waterways. Each of these toxins poses risks to children’s development and health.
Waste ponds also contain fracking chemicals, which return to the surface with the waste water. The chemicals used in fracking fluids include respiratory toxins, carcinogens, immune system toxins, and endocrine disruptors. Endocrine disruptors are of particular concern to children’s health. Infants, children and developing fetuses are the most vulnerable to exposure to endocrine disrupting chemicals. Exposure at these critical stages of development can affect fetal growth, reproductive tract development, pubertal development, neurodevelopment and obesity. Research from Dr. Theo Colborn(4) indicates that 40% of chemicals in fracking fluids are endocrine disruptors, both volatile and water-soluble.
Heavy truck traffic – estimated at 2,400 truck trips per frack per well(5) – as well as drill pad machinery generate large quantities of diesel fuel combustion products. Diesel combustion products have multiple health impacts. Pre-natal exposure to diesel fuel combustion products is a known risk for low birth weight. Low birth weight is a major indicator of child health, and is associated with multiple health and learning issues throughout life.
Asthma is the most common chronic disease of childhood, and diesel combustion products are linked to increased asthma attacks. Another contributor to increased asthma is increased ozone. Rural areas in Wyoming and Utah with intensive gas drilling have measured ozone levels higher than the worst days in smoggy Los Angeles. Gas drilling areas of Colorado, Texas, Wyoming and Utah have all recorded ozone levels exceeding federal health standards. The Utah Bureau of Land Management identified concentrated natural gas and oil development in the Uintah Basin as the primary cause of the ozone pollution in that area.(6)
In Texas, the hospital serving the six intensively drilled counties in the state recorded asthma rates three times the state average. “It seems highly likely there will be impacts on children with asthma that lead to hospitalizations, lost school days and higher health care costs,” wrote the American Lung Association in a submission to New York’s review of hydraulic fracturing.
Ozone can also increase cancer risks. “Ozone is not a carcinogen per se, but animal studies show that, because it creates inflammation, it can raise the risk for metastases,” notes Dr. Sandra Steingraber.(7)
There are few studies, and no hard answers, to determine exactly how much risk there is to children or adult health from shale gas development, but the risks appear considerable. A 2012 peer-reviewed study by researchers at the Colorado School of Public Health(8), found that residents living within half a mile of a gas well faced 66% greater cancer risks than residents living farther away. They also found a 150% increase in non-cancer risks, including neurological, respiratory and developmental impacts.
Photo Credit: The Purple Violet Press
Children’s environmental exposures are becoming increasingly recognized as potential contributors to a range of diseases. “We know now that children may have genetic vulnerabilities for such conditions as autism, brain cancers and other chronic diseases, but that environmental insults can trigger the onset or progression,” says pediatric neurologist Dr Maya Shetreat-Klein, assistant clinical professor of Neurology at Albert Einstein College of Medicine.
Noise pollution may seem like a minor impact, but noise from drilling 24/7 is an additional risk to children’s health and ability to learn. The World Health Organization labels noise pollution “not only an environmental nuisance, but also a threat to public health.” Noise pollution has also been shown to negatively affect academic performance.
Environmental exposures are involuntary exposures. Parents living in an area with shale gas development cannot protect their children from exposure to multiple airborne toxins, or from other exposures stemming from the industry.
The New Brunswick College of Family Physicians is the first major health organization in Canada to call for a moratorium on shale gas development and fracking, “until further research can prove that the benefits clearly outweigh the risks.”(9)
Medical staff at Sackville Memorial Hospital supported the College’s call for a moratorium, noting, “We believe that the health of children including the unborn may be especially at risk. We believe that adequate health studies do not yet exist to fully understand the health risks of this industry and that more studies are needed.”(10)
Health professionals in the US urge caution. “First do no harm,” wrote Dr. Madelon Finkel, in the American Journal of Public Health. “If you have an industry where there are, in a sense, known dangers, don’t go forward until you’ve actually analyzed and assessed what these dangers are.”(11)
Health is not just a matter of percentages and statistics. It’s also a matter of the heart. Environmental biologist and mother, Sandra Steingraber, author of Raising Elijah, is an eloquent advocate for the need to ban fracking for unconventional gas in New York State and elsewhere:
“… the bodies of my children are the rearranged molecules of the air, water, and food streaming through them. As their mother, there is no more important investment that I could make right now than to support the fight for the integrity of the ecological system that makes their lives possible.”(12)
Barb Harris is a writer and researcher with a special interest in environmental toxins and human health. Over the past year, she has focused on the potential health impacts of shale gas and fracking. She is co-author of the on-line Guide to Less Toxic Products, and a core member of the Environmental Health Association of Nova Scotia (EHANS.) She lives in River John, Nova Scotia.
MORE FROM BARB HARRIS:
- Hear Barb’s interview on the Health Impacts of Fracking for Shale Gas on CBC’s Shift
Other articles in this series:
- Fracking, Shale Gas and Cancer: Health Risks at Every Step, An Ounce, Winter 2012
- Fracking, Shale Gas and Health: A Case for Precaution, An Ounce, Summer 2011
- Fracking could taint water systems, study finds, Ottawa Citizen, August 7, 2012
- N.B. well water in oil and gas area contaminated with methane and chemicals, CBC News, August 1, 2012
- Pro Publica investigative reporting Fracking series, 2012
- Issue Paper on Hydraulic Fracturing and Unconventional Gas Practices, Nova Scotia Resource and Action Coalition
- Toxic Chemicals Used in Fracking, US House of Representatives Committee on Commerce, April 2011
- Physicians, Scientists & Engineers for Healthy Energy library of relevant resources, including peer reviewed articles
- Natural Gas Operations from a Public Health Perspective ,Theo Colborn, Carol Kwiatkowski, Kim Schultz, and Mary Bachran, International Journal of Human and Ecological Risk Assessment, September 4, 2010
- PEHSU Information on Natural Gas Extraction and Hydraulic Fracturing for Health Professionals
- Colborn, Ibid
- NYSDEC Draft SGEIS
- Cancer in the Ransom Note, Sandra Steingraber, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/sandra-steingraber/cancer-in-the-ransom-note_b_1369459.html
- Human health risk assessment of air emissions from development of unconventional natural gas resources, McKenzie, Witter, Newman, Adgate, Colorado School of Public Health, University of Colorado, Science of the Total Environment 424 (2012) 79–87
- The Rush to Drill for Natural Gas: A Public Health Cautionary Tale, Madelon L. Finkel, Adam Law, American Journal of Public Health, May 2011
- Why I’m donating my Heinz Award Money to the Fight Against Fracking, Sandra Steingraber, September 13, 2011
- Warning: Your mobile gadgets can be hazardous to your heath
Fracking, Shale Gas and Children’s Health: Toxins and vulnerable populations
- Go Home – Talk to Your Fish
- Camille’s Yummy Summer Recipe: The Watermelon Slushy
- Time to end the Corruption of Public Health Policy by the asbestos industry
- Let’s study the health impact of the Tar Sands too!
- Celebrating the Life of Dr. Rosalie Bertell (1929-2012)
- Best to avoid that new car smell
- Defeating incinerators one community at a time
- We need to create a pesticide-free environment if we’re going to prevent cancer
- Donate to PCN – We need you!
- PCN Shorts…
- Please take 2 minutes and complete our readship survey!
Published: August 15th, 2012